“The undeniable truth is that neither slavery nor Jim Crow nor the harshest racism has decimated the black family the way the welfare state has,” said George Mason professor Walter Williams in an article that can be found here.
There is little evidence to support the idea that slavery, racial discrimination and poverty caused the problems of today’s black Americans, the economics professor wrote.
The number one problem is the weak family structure:
In 1960, just 22 percent of black children were raised in single-parent families.
Fifty years later, more than 70 percent of black children were raised in single-parent families.
According to the 1938 Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences, that year 11 percent of black children were born to unwed mothers. Today about 75 percent of black children are born to unwed mothers. That can’t be a legacy of slavery, it can’t be some delayed reaction.
As Professor Williams said, the bottom line is that the black family was stronger the first 100 years after slavery than during what will be the second 100 years.
All blacks were poor originally but now 30 percent are poor. Two-parent black families are rarely poor.
Only 8 percent of black married-couple families live in poverty. Among black families in which both the husband and wife work full time, the poverty rate is under 5 percent. Poverty in black families headed by single women is 37 percent.
It’s the welfare state that decimated the black family, he concludes.
Facts … and the left will deny and avoid these forever, because it puts responsibility for their lives, on them. As it is in this life.
You are right
The great Walter E. Williams. His rise to prominence was aided by none other than Rush Limbaugh. Yup. Rush would have Dr. Williams guest host on his show. He was terrific. Believe it was Walter who said, I’m paraphrasing, if he was at the highest level of the KKK he couldn’t have come up with a better way to ruin the Black Family than welfare.
This is the scholar black folks should look up to and try to emulate….he has more sense in his little finger than the whole NFL….
William Watson, you are just what we need, another white man telling us what’s best for us!!!
He’s black not white.
Rush introduced his audience to the brilliance of Walter William’s and Thomas Sowell showing us listeners their insights and educating us more than the government indoctrination schools do.
Bill, truth has no color. Neither does ignorance and denial. If you disagree you are probably one of those the professor is talking about.
I thought racism was something we abhor whether it be white racism or black … Rush is white. Do we know if Bill is?
Does it really matter what race he is if he’s right?
It’s not about if he is right or wrong , he is only representing his research, I am just curious if he saw the amount these poor families received because if the amount was sufficient enough to secure safe housing and living allowance then Welfare would not have been the cause…who could raise children and family based on what they qualified for? Who?Quality of living and breakdown of family structure was compromised because it was programmed that way to fail. Same situation with the homelessness…and waiting for 30 days on the streets with children so that paper work can be processed lead many to commit suicide or get killed on the streets while waiting for housing and relief.
When LBJ expanded welfare in his Great Society, it was only allowed when one parent was absent from the children’s home. This was deliberate in order to destroy the black family, give government more control over them and get the minority vote. LBJ even bragged about it. He was a closet racist. Same reason he tried to empty the inner cities with the draft, expanding the war to justify it. The biggest con job by the party of the confederacy.
William
, you should listen to Soul and Williams – both Black, both brilliant and great mentors for people like you.
Just what we need, another racist spewing hate at someone because of their race.
If he’s white I’m a unicorn
Walter Williams was already a big deal before hosting the Rush Limbaugh show. He was very good hosting though. I would always try to be in my office when he hosted. I liked him better than Rush.
Walter Williams and Thomas Sowell are the voice of sanity in the black community. What is odd is that Sowell actually started out as a Marxist and then saw the light. I also love watching Candace Owens tear the liberal congressmen a new asshole. A few blacks are finally starting to see through the Democrat plan to hold them back by keeping them dependent on the Democrat Party.
May the #WalkAway movement continue to grow as Dems get really “woke” to the truth.
If not for Rush and listening to him since 1987 I would not know who these great thinkers are. Always wished I could influence my friends to listen.
Leaned much when Mr. William’s was guest host!
You got to hand it to the Dems: they created racism, fought against abolition, founded the KKK, fought against equal rights in the 60s. They then learned to enslave our people economically with welfare and keep us voting for them to keep the money coming, all the while convincing us that we are being oppressed by those that freed us. Brilliant…
Its not brilliant its sad to think that the bulk of the black community still think just the opposite and are blind to the liberals enslaving them in the 21st century.
Yes sad. The same thing has happened in the native American reservations. Gov. took over and the ability and desire to work collapsed. God said if a man will not work he will not eat. Men get their feeling of accomplishment from their job. All men need to work to have strong self worth. We need to retrain our youth!
Well said Edwin!
Brilliant or evil?
Then where are the stats on welfare in this article? It’s just a statement at the end. Typical conjecture which is applied for all other arguments on the right.
The article I read has “stats” in it. Not enough? I suggest you use your internet access to do a little of your own research. Seriously though, it’s an obvious connection.
I will add that it’s humorous that you use the communist method of blaming and labeling others for what you are doing No facts, lies and propaganda.
“PROJECTION”!!! You nailed it. It’s rampant today!
Granya, I noticed you did not offer evidence to the contrary. All you did was
verify the truth of his article.
It’s not welfare it’s self. It’s the effects of welfare and the “nanny State”in general. Government benefits reward you for removing the Father from the home. Probably the biggest problems for families of any race is a single parent home. The article said around the time the “great society” was implemented black single parent homes was I think 22%. Compared to the present day 75%.
The Black family were the guinea pigs for the overall plan for the liberals to take control of America, you must nip it in the bud, destroy the family, destroy America, take a look around you, families are falling apart, emasculated males, empowered females, the left knows exactly what they are doing, if we don’t change this NOW, America will fall.
Amen to That!!
Amen to all of it. Get off your ass, get a job, and get on birth control, or get a husband, and most of your problems will disappear.
Yes and family court played a major role in removing the Fathers
Family court sucks no question. But it had nothing to do with this conversation. Facts are black women have children without a good man to father
Black families in the South after the Civil War were strong and took care of those who were not making it. The Aunts pitched in when a mother could not bring up kids. Then welfare struck and husbands became a financial liability an actual family was almost illegal when applying for any type of government assistance.
The drug “free stuff” began to erode the family and led to what we have now. The continued use of this drug does not allow individuals to dig out of poverty and government “rules.” Democrats have taken advantage of this state of affairs to scare these individuals into voting for them with their dire stories of GOP cuts in welfare and poverty programs. Nice closed circle of mutual destruction.
I saw it happen. Young black girls heard about getting money if you have a baby. That’s the beginning and end of the black family unit. I could write a book on what I saw happen. And YES the Dems created the enslavement. It’s buying the vote
Back in the 1960’s a friend was teaching in NY state when a female student informed her that she (student) did not need to learn that subject as she was going to have babies and the government would support her. Thanks LBJ for creating the dependent mentality.
This is the real root of the problem, it’s not cops, it’s not racism, it’s not Trump or Republicans, it is, and has been this fact that i s the problem, now let’s fix that, let’s protest that….
Williams and all of the posters here are delusional. Because you deny the existence of American racism doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist—it means you choose to acknowledge the reality. Captured Africans were made in to slaves and that slave labor drove the country’s early economy. Those slaves were stripped of their humanity and dignity and were seen as “property”. White slave owners benefited and became wealthy–denying black the most basic God given privileges. This was the Genesis if racism/white supremacy. With the “ending” of legal slavery came Jim Crow—which further denied blacks their human rights. (And we will talk about how white men systematically slaughtered Native American tribes to take the land–in another conversation). The legacy of slavery and Jim Crow are instrumental in the oppression that black people continue to face.
And what of the black slave owners? Are they given a free pass? What of the African Tribal Elders that owned slaves before the white man ever did? What of slave owners today?
Who said there’s no racism or injustice? It’s the Democrats who are responsible for slavery, Jim Crow, and the current divisiveness.
Nat, European Whites rarely captured Blacks, buying them from Black and Arab captors. Are you alleging that capturing people for slavery is fine as long as you don’t use them as slaves? When Jim Crow ended, as evil as it was, the Black families were largely intact. How did the end of Jim Crow laws cause the breakdown of Black families? Welfare regulations about able-bodied males being excluded is well documented.
Who was it that “captured” these Africans and enslaved them in the first place Nat? You are the one who is spreading the delusional narrative that the white European colonials were going into Africa and taking slaves by force.
The truth is, it was Islamic Arabs and the stronger tribal leaders on Africa’s West coast who “captured”, and then enslaved Negros from the weaker African tribes.
Did the white European colonials, and then white American plantation owners, unjustly benefit from the African slave trade? Yes, but so did a whole bunch of Africans and Muslims.
The notion that white Europeans, and then White southern plantation owners, were the only culprits in the African slave trade is not a true historical reality.
Well Nat, if America whitey is SO bad, why stay here? A lot of black countries you can go to. Just saying.
Nat, the most racist people I have known have been blacks.
So you think slavery in 1800 forced today’s tramps to mate with any piece of trash they could to make babys so they wouldn’t have to work. And many of them keep these good for nothing, lazy, nonworking “fiances” around and feed them with the government support meant for the litters of offspring.
Nat Turner: The vast majority of white people never owned a slave.,
Almost ALL of today’s whites are at least partially descended from immigrants who came here after the civil war, and never owned a slave. There were 35 million Americans in 1865, according to census records. At least 20 million immigrants arrived into the US after 1865 and between 1900, and many more immigrants after that time.
It appears that I’m “pure” post 1865 immigrant stock. All my U.S. forebearers seem to have come to America after 1880 or so.
Does that mean I don’t owe reparations for slavery? Silly question.
No you have to pay double reparations because your people were late getting to the tax paying table. Plus two minorities get to vote twice for a Democrat in the next election!
I have traveled the world. All children are precious until some are corrupted by parents or their environment
Well said Mike! And true!
In the 1960s my parents said, in our little town in Missouri, social workers were telling black couples to divorce but live together. That way they would get Aid to Dependant Children. This was the beginning of the break-up of the black families….the Great Society. And it was done by the democratic government.
You do realize that humans caught for slaves were the weakest of the race? Just like animals that are hunted as Prey by the Predator, the slow, the weak, the young and old, the inexperienced, are taken out because in nature only the strong survive. Example, watch a Leopard going in for the kill on a herd and see who gets eaten. If your past ancestors were slaves you should be thankful that they were wanted as workers and not as food by Predators, otherwise you won’t be here. Bring on the hate for pointing out the obvious. PS, my ancestors never owned a slave.
Don’t forget what LBJ said about the Great Society: “We will have those ni**ers voting democratic for the next 200 years.”
I believe he’s on track to be proven to be right. He also said ” we have to give them something for their vote. Not enough to make a difference. Just enough to keep their vote”.
In 2014, Cliven Bundy was demonized for saying basically the same thing. Was it because he was a white man saying it or was he didn’t say it with eloquence that offended so many?
— Follow Cliven Bundy American Patriot–
And if this guy did not go out of his way to show and prove that he’s, “Not like those other blacks,” conservatives would assume that he too was just another typical black person. This guy is not promoting upward movement for the black community. He’s renting himself out to republicans so they can use this as a tool to scold blacks without looking racist. He says everything that they WISH they could say out loud, but are afraid to for fear of looking racist and losing their jobs. So…cue in as many black conservatives as possible to help us. Dumb! I’m a firm believer in the saying, you can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar. Learn to TALK to people. Not AT or ABOUT them. Create healthy dialogue. Ask questions and listen. But people don’t believe in doing that. Seriously…..I doubt if any NFL players are on welfare. So is this black guy and his talks of welfare supposed to inspire them to “act right and stay in their place?” It would help a lot if this guy provided resources to help the black people he’s talking about. People DON’T WANT to live on welfare. Some people know what they want to do. Some people have a vision. Problem is, they don’t have the resources to go about achieving their goals. Instead of exploiting them…try helping.
Welfare runs in generations so people do CHOOSE to live on welfare.
With all do respect, I’ve heard from many
African Americans say this is a white mans world and a black man cant make it if people believe that it’s no wonder they live in poverty and government assistance especially if your children hear it all their lives
Joy N. Smith, your statements here are the most ignorant blather I have read in a long time. If you dont think blacks choose to live on Welfare you are ill informed! The choice to bear children out of wedlock is a choice. The choice to teach your children racism and hatred for whites is a choice. 40 million blacks in America and over 28 million blacks on welfare is not a choice? Dont be ridiculous.
Joy, you are saying that any black man who does not toe the victim line is an Uncle Tom.
You cannot take any people, of any color, and exempt them from the requirements of civilization — including work, behavioral standards, personal responsibility and all the other basic things that the clever intelligentsia disdain — without ruinous consequences to them and to society at large.
Thomas Sowell
Your generalities are unsubstantiated.
That comment is addressed to Joy.
The limitations and the structure of the “Welfare” System , indeed, has/is playing a major role on the in decimating “black” families. But it’s just one of many systems. This structure of the “Welfare” system will not aid a family in need but it will give assistance to unwed or divorced women, particularly. So who set the system up like this and why? See, the article conveniently left out many details of the determent of the “Welfare” system.
It was Lyndon Johnson wasn’t it? Welfare came in under him. Including rules about supporting single mothers, not family
The administration of Lyndon’s welfare system created a situation where the BEST thing that a poor black man could do for his family was to leave it. Sad!
Read my previous comment it is the liberals that blacks continue to flock to that is the problem. Abandon the Democrat party all together, they want to keep blacks on the plantation to secure the vote. I am old enough to remember the strong, proud black family unit. Your good old Democrats made it so a family that needed assistance couldn’t get it if there was a man in the household. This one move destroyed the black family, and created the thug mentality we have today. This was your good old Democrats led by Lyndon Baines Johnson and his Horrible Great Society.
Liberals set it up like that. Have you read any comments other than your own? Even Malcolm x said that the worst enemy for black people was the white liberals. The way liberals pretend to pander to blacks to get their vote really has created the modern day plantation. They come around every 4 years and make promises to help black people and screw “the man” to keep you on the plantation. Then do NOTHING to help you. I saw where you were complaining about unfair sentencing and prison time that was implemented by guess who. Liberals and the Clintons. Yet they are loved by black people. Who finally got some legislation pushed through to correct Some of the problems? Not Obama, Trump. But you call him a white supremacists. Makes no sense. You also stated that there is rampant racially motivated home loans and credit discrimination. That is simply not true. There are many federal and state laws dedicated specifically to prevent that. Unless they come from a fairly well off family, just about any young black person can go to college on 100%grants. I am a straight white Christian male. There are exactly zero laws to make sure I get treated fairly. Change any one of those 4 adjectives to ANYTHING else and you instantly become part of at least one protected class. I’m part of the only demographic who you say or do anything to and it’s socially acceptable.
This professor just gave Caucasians a free pass and all but completely denied, all the institutionalized injustices implemented to the determent of “black” people. What a shame.
Oshaylinux, once again you blame the white community for all wrongs. You must stop teaching your children to hate the white man. In turn you need to accept responsibility for your own failings. Over 50% of crimes are committed by blacks that only make up 13.5% of the population. Single parent homes are the culprit. Poor parenting is the culprit.
Interesting, based on what you posted, what excuse does poor Caucasians have for their misfortunes? Why is it that people of color are sentenced more harshly for crimes equal to or less in some cases than Caucasians? Why it easier for the average Caucasians to get a bank loan than it is for an average people of color? Why do banks charge people of color higher interest rates on loans than Caucasians? See, i know you’re just as much a victim to this same system as people of color but you choice to believe the system is for you.
Interesting. Based on Credit rating, income loan history. Not, race.
Always blame the system and never take any responsibility. If you want to blame someone then blame the Liberals, and specifically the white liberals. Black liberals are just trying to make a buck off their people. The white liberal is condescending, and actually believes, that blacks are incapable of taking care of themselves. Remove the liberal element and all people would get along great.
There will always be racial and ethnic bias. The law cannot read minds and hearts. I’m Italian and dark-complexed. I know that’s held me back now and then over the passed 70 years. But I don’t care. God deals you a hand in life and you okay it no matter what. Excuses just stop you in your tracks. If you wait around for justice and some sense of social balance to suddenly overtake the world, you’ll waste your life. Excuses are insidious. It is YOU who decide when to stop; when to go.
The very first thing to help blacks is to remove ‘African’ from their nationality. They are Americans.
Thank you. The only true African Americans were born in Africa but most have assimilated into the USA culture and have become Americans through citizenship.
And they also do not have to be black. South African whites who immigrate to the US are African Americans.
Everyone has to be recognized in some way. Doesn’t matter to me which way. African American, black American, or what ever. But please make up their mind. It just seems that it changes every few years. I’m not here to hurt anyone feelings. It just seems like some one is always getting hurt
I absolutely agree. It’s crazy how people are going in on how lazy black men and women are and how they sit on their butts. But I have seen good black men with legal jobs who take care of their wives and children be almost snatched out of their homes. I am convinced that the government does not want the black family to be strong
In this article you claimed his column was in The Richmond Times-Dispatch. I can not find anywhere. Trying to prove a point. Could you send the link please.
Here is the link to the original article.
https://www.creators.com/read/walter-williams/09/17/the-welfare-states-legacy
Thank you. They move the links.
You can thank LBJ and his democrat cronies. His quoted purpose “to keep those N_____ on the plantation.” The same treatment we did to Native Americans after we stole their land and their dignity of self provision.
Lyndon Johnson hurt minorities as much as Margaret Saenger
How is this a black family thing? This is for all races and family’s.
Why is there a reluctance to accept this long available analysis?? Such a destructive policy. Fear of admitting such an error? Or the pursuit of votes and power over doing right policy. Or emotionally driven thought (compassion)?
When we all look beyond color as a criteria for job pay, social standing, and personal friendships the world will be a better place for all of us. My 23& me reflected 1% African genetics which I am PROUD to be!
All according to the margaret sanger/john d rockefeller plan, that was furthered by johnson and nixon, and with bush 1’s help that has now escalated into blatant socialism.
ALL financed and CONTROLLED by the Federal Reserve
Thank you for sharing what any honest and realistic person can see as truth.
The media lies about this
“These Negroes, they’re getting pretty uppity these days and that’s a problem for us since they’ve got something now they never had before, the political pull to back up their uppityness. Now we’ve got to do something about this, we’ve got to give them a little something, just enough to quiet them down, not enough to make a difference.”
The Democrat Party and Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society (1964/1965) doomed the progress of black communities!
https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/did-lbj-say-ill-have-those-nggers-voting-democratic-200-years
Not demanding illegals get deported is what’s destroying everything.
I agree with his statement. These people are more of a slave today than when there were plantations.
The other failure is the education system, they have failed the kids and don’t provide them with a meaningful education. They dumb down tests or the pass the kids to keep their numbers up.