Important Ruling! FBI Must Reveal Efforts to Verify the Steele Dossier


In light of the declassification and the release of the Nunes and Schiff Memoranda, Judge Mehta has reversed his prior decision and is rejecting the FBI’s refusal to confirm or deny the existence of records reflecting an attempt to verify the two-page synopsis allegations from the Steele Dossier.

A Washington DC judge ruled that the FBI must respond to a FOIA request for documents concerning the bureau’s efforts to verify the controversial Steele dossier before it was used as the foundation of a FISA surveillance warrant application and subsequent renewals. They must give the documents to Judicial Watch.

The FBI has been fighting the release of that information. It seems one reason they are doing that is to keep the public from knowing how thorough or not thorough they were in compiling the dossier. Conservative Republicans contend the FBI did not try to verify it and, in fact, colluded with the Clinton campaign and Fusion GPS to invent the document.

The document was used fraudulently, they believe, to obtain a FISA warrant to spy on Trump campaign aide Carter Page. That warrant allowed the FBI to also spy “incidentally” on anyone Page was in contact with during the 2016 campaign.


U.S. District Court Judge Amit Mehta [an Obama judge] in January sided with the FBI’s decision to ignore the FOIA request. However, he said that President Trump’s release of two House Intelligence Committee documents (the “Nunes” and “Schiff” memos) changed the situation.

In January, Mehta concurred with the FBI’s decision to not disclose the existence of any records containing the agency’s efforts to verify the dossier. He ruled that Trump’s tweets about the dossier didn’t require the FBI and other intelligence agencies to act on records requests.

“But then the ground shifted,” writes Mehta of Trump declassifying the House memos. “As a result of the Nunes and Schiff Memos, there is now in the public domain meaningful information about how the FBI acquired the Dossier and how the agency used it to investigate Russian meddling.”

“It remains no longer logical nor plausible for the FBI to maintain that it cannot confirm nor deny the existence of documents,” Mehta wrote.

“It is simply not plausible to believe that, to whatever extent the FBI has made efforts to verify Steele’s reporting, some portion of that work has not been devoted to allegations that made their way into the synopsis. After all, if the reporting was important enough to brief the President-elect, then surely the FBI thought enough of those key charges to attempt to verify their accuracy,” he continued.


To make a long story short, the FBI must show what they did to verify the claims contained within the Nunes and Schiff memos.

The information about this ruling showed up on Politico’s, Under the Radar, and it is a big deal.

It won’t go into effect immediately because the case was on appeal to the D.C. Circuit when Trump approved the release of the House memos. The appeals court is now likely to remand the case to Mehta to determine whether the FBI has other grounds to withhold records about verifying the dossier.

Dossier believers will find it ironic if the President’s decision to declassify those two documents ends up hanging him. However, given the FBI’s lack of transparency, it’s more likely it will expose them.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
4 years ago

99% of Hillary’s reptilian brain is devoted to acquiring power and skirting the law. I believe she could have done this with the assistance of Obama and his “sorority sisters.”

4 years ago

Since the FISA requests omitted important information, and did not contain verification, they are invalid, and the judges are suspect. Verification info would have long ago been released if it were to make Trump look bad.

4 years ago
Reply to  V.Lombardi

I believe your right, just like Amorosa, if she had a tape of Trump using the N word we would have heard it long ago. All the Trump hating media would not sit on anything that could be considered bad news for Trump. Someone makes an accusation against Trump and the Fake News Pedalers blow it up 6 ways from Sunday without verifiying the info.The majority of people have tuned out the Trump hate rhetoric from the MSM, many do not watch anymore. I don’t have a clue why any business would advertise on the news shows when nobody is watching anymore, they even ignore it in the airport.
The MSM have cried “Wolf” for the last 2+yrs, so much so that if Mueller turns up anything on Trump “we the People” either won’t hear it or we won’t believe it, especially since the things that Trump is doing is making things better for America and actually with regards to NK & Iran, making the world a safer place.

Voice of Reason
Voice of Reason
4 years ago

Bill might’ve been the mastermind, but it could just as well have been Obama himself! In any case, it was likely executed by Hillary and the DNC, and the cabal of collusion extended into the highest levels of the FBI and CIA, so you can bet your bottom dollar they’ll be using every slimy trick at their disposal to save their own skins and preserve their “firewalls”, even if it means destroying or altering the evidence.

Steve Ford
Steve Ford
4 years ago

Everyone is focusing and looking in the wrong place. I never thought Hillary was smart enough to concoct up such a scheme as this dossier and weave it thru so many hands, to make it look like Trump was the culprit in this fake Russian collusion debacle. I have seen for some time now Bill Clinton’s nasty finger prints all over this. This is his brain at work, and Hillary, and all the other players were following Bill’s lead. He has the political smarts and the devilish smile to go with it.

4 years ago

Is this EVER going to end? I realize the level of institutional, historic corruption is profound but I for one am utterly fatigued not just at the 24/7 Hysterical Lunatics on the left (AntiF[irst]A[mendment], MSM, HollyWeird, etc) but when there is BLATANT criminal activity before our eyes…..they still chase after this country-harming ‘collusion’ fantasy – something, ANYTHING. Punish the CORRECT targets already!