Strategist on a far-left publication says Trump was right about China


Check out the title of this Atlantic article by Nadia Schadlow, a former deputy national security adviser for strategy: The Trump administration’s National Security Strategy challenged the assumption that international organizations are always driven by a common global good. China’s undue influence

Consider the Possibility That Trump Is Right About China

The article continues with this train of thought. Schadlow, who worked for Trump, is saying President Trump was right about China all along and the Atlantic actually printed it.

This is in The Atlantic. It’s amazing they published it.

She began by describing the view held by his critics and then explaining why Trump is right:

When a new coronavirus emerged in China and began spreading around the world, including in the United States, President Donald Trump’s many critics in the American foreign-policy establishment were quick to identify him as part of the problem. Trump had campaigned on an “America first” foreign policy, which after his victory was enshrined in the official National Security Strategy that his administration published in 2017. At the time, I served in the administration and orchestrated the writing of that document. In the years since Trump has been criticized for supposedly overturning the post–World War II order and rejecting the role the United States has long played in the world. Amid a global pandemic, he’s being accused—on this site and elsewhere—of alienating allies, undercutting multinational cooperation, and causing America to fight the coronavirus alone.

And yet even as the current emergency has proved him right in fundamental ways—about China specifically and foreign policy more generally—many respectable people in the United States are letting their disdain for the president blind them to what is really going on in the world. Far from discrediting Trump’s point of view, the COVID-19 crisis reveals what his strategy asserted: that the world is a competitive arena in which great power rivals like China seek advantage, that the state remains the irreplaceable agent of international power and effective action, that international institutions have limited capacity to transform the behavior and preferences of states.

China, America’s most powerful rival, has played a particularly harmful role in the current crisis, which began on its soil.

It’s a lengthy article and well worth reading. Her conclusion is right on:

Contrary to what critics argue, “America first” does not mean “America alone.” That Trump might be introducing needed correctives to the hyper-globalization pursued by earlier administrations is generating serious cognitive dissonance in some quarters. And the reality is that only one organization in the entire world has as its sole responsibility the American people’s safety. That institution is the U.S. government. Whether led by Republicans or Democrats—or by Donald Trump or anyone else—it should always put the American people first.


0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments